Who Should Start for the U.S. Against England?

It’s Wednesday, people—just three days out from U.S.-England, and our World Cup Fever is now officially > our Bieber Fever.

Which is saying something, because there is no cure for Bieber Fever—if you doubt it, click here (sorry about the ad at the start).

So who should the U.S. start against the Three Lions on Saturday? Here’s our take:


Tim Howard. Uh, yep.


Steve Cherundolo. In better form than Spector right now; poised veteran.

Jay DeMerit. We actually think he matches up well with Wayne Rooney, on a physical level, anyway. Athletic scrapper.

Oguchi Onyewu. We’re not sure he’s 100% yet, but we don’t want to face England with Clarence Goodson in the heart of the defense.

Carlos Bocanegra. Best left back option.

Outlook: All kinds of problems here. Not a particularly speedy group, and Onyewu is still rounding into form. Could Bradley throw—gulp—Jonathan Bornstein, his fastest defender, out there for more cover against ultra-quick England winger Aaron Lennon?



Clint Dempsey. Most reliable big-game player on the team, he will bring it.

Michael Bradley. Ball-winner, attack-squelcher, and he can get forward and score goals. Has a tendency to overheat and draw cards, though.

Maurice Edu. Many of the same qualities as Bradley but more skilled and a better passer.

Landon Donovan. They’ve heard of him in England.

Outlook: We like this group; every player is proven at the highest level. Bradley has shown a preference for the Ricardo Clark-Michael Bradley pairing in the middle, and may well go with that versus England, but we think Edu is a better option: He breaks up attacks just as well, and is a better passer than Clark. But as Soccer America’s Ridge Mahoney argues here, in detail, Clark is not without a number of underappreciated attributes.


Jozy Altidore. Latest reports have him on target to recover in time from his recent ankle sprainHe’s a trial for any defender.

Robbie Findley. We were his biggest doubters two weeks ago, and yet now we think he’s ready. (We are more fickle than a restless sea.) Findley flubbed two clear chances in the tuneup against Australia this past Saturday, but that just means he’ll collect himself and put them away in the next game, right? Right.

Outlook: Charlie Davies will be hugely missed, obviously. The crop of U.S. forwards in South Africa is strikingly inexperienced (and the most blooded of the group, Altidore, is only 20 years old) and facing England in a World Cup opener is a baptism by fire, if not napalm.

On the other hand, Findley and especially Edson Buddle looked like they were playing with the house’s money on Saturday against Australia: Taking guys on, full of confidence, and in Buddle’s case, bagging two goals. They have nothing to lose, and seem fired up to just play loose and go for it.

Here’s another option: Bradley starts the in-form Buddle alongside the speedy Findley, thereby giving him a hot goal-scorer, and a speedster to keep England’s backline on notice—something he might want from the get-go in this high-pressure affair.

Then he has the option of bringing on The Handful that Is Jozy Altidore against a fatigued England backline in the second half. Hmmmm.

Anyway, that’s just us spitballing. What’s your ideal lineup to face England? Let us know in the comments.


4 comments on “Who Should Start for the U.S. Against England?

  1. Blake says:

    Cherundolo, Boca, Goodson, Spector (Demerit and Gooch are out of form)
    Dempsey, Bradley, Edu, Donovan
    Buddle, Findley

  2. abes army says:

    My prediction is howard, cherundolo, demerit, goodson, bocanegra, dempsey, bradley, clark, donovan, buddle and findley.

  3. Chris says:

    Howard, Cherundolo, DeMerit, Gooch, Bocanegra, Dempsey, Bradley, Edu, Donovan, Buddle, and Altidore. Findley and Holden as 2nd half subs. 1-1 final score, with the US going on top early and holding on for the tie, despite England dominating play.

  4. Marc says:

    Did I read your post correctly? Did you really say that Edu is a better passer than Bradley and suggest that he is the better player? Hmmm. C’mon Backpost, you’re better than that. In any event, I agree with your starting XI, except believe that Clark will start. I think Buddle and Jozy are too similar, and I think Jozy’s confidence would take a hit if he doesn’t start against England. I know Spector played like crap against Turkey, but I don’t understand why he hasn’t been given a look on the left. I think Gooch will get torched by Rooney, and agree that Goodson is too error prone (though he is great on set pieces). I would like to see Torres, but think it makes more sense to hold him out until Slovenia.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s